News Fix # 69: we need a stronger and broader foundation

Wooden stilt house built over water drawn in continuous line art style
Credit: Alicja for AdobeStock

I'm back with your weekly news fix, and I'm happy we're in this together. If you're new here, welcome! Get in touch anytime; I'd love to hear from you. If you've been reading for a while, will you forward this to somebody you'd like to bring into the conversation? I'd appreciate it.

Sitting on a blessedly on-time and uninterrupted flight home Sunday afternoon, I was scrolling through The New York Times headlines before takeoff. This one stood out, perhaps for obvious reasons: “Behind Tech Crisis, Ecosystems That Stack Innovations on Archaic Foundations.”

Even though I was sitting on a plane with people who had been stuck in airports for days because of a tech problem, in my mind I almost immediately swapped out the word “tech” for “journalism.” The word “ecosystem” really made that statement seem like an accurate diagnosis of news.

My flight was taking me home from a Reynolds Journalism Institute workshop. A few of us who have already turned over stewardship of news organizations to other leaders were tasked with helping founders think through how and when to plan leadership transitions for themselves.

In the two years since I stepped away from Outlier, keeping a small and high-quality news organization on solid footing seems to have only gotten more difficult. These founders and the people they want to serve are all navigating an exponentially increasing pace of change in the informational environment. Fundraising is getting harder. The information needs many of these news organizations hope to address are no less pressing.

These leaders seem burned out, almost to a person. That each of them spent a weekend carefully assessing how to best prepare their news organizations to thrive without them at some point is a testament to their persistence. It's their attempt to build a strong organizational foundation despite headwinds that make it difficult. That RJI and its funders are stepping in with some support for these organizations is meaningful. It is not sufficient, of course, but it does help.

The resilience of our civic health relies on these folks at the local level being able to continue to deliver more valuable journalism to more people. We require their innovation. We have not done enough to modernize our archaic foundations to make this more likely.

If you could make a change in the foundation of our journalism ecosystem so that innovations built on top of it were more likely to matter and create real value for people in their everyday lives, what would that one thing be?

You know my obsessions: cleaving our definition of journalism's utility from market success, for example. Or developing an essential functions framework to replace weird and also outdated ideas about news values. Or placing journalism inside a healthy civic information ecosystem rather than trying to dominate such a system.

Those are some foundational ideas about news I'd like to see rebuilt. What are some ideas you find archaic?

Strengthen and broaden

It isn't easy to identify our assumptions about how the news must be, let alone challenge them. The difficulty is not just intellectual but practical. It takes a lot of time, energy, and coordination to make any reimagining actually happen.

Those of us who want a better journalism and civic information ecosystem are working urgently to realize these ambitions. But like the founders I worked alongside this past weekend, we are trying to build carefully. We want to broaden the field to strengthen it.

The News Futures working group I'm part of is looking for community-led, local, non-newsroom groups that share critical information, help make sense of community issues, and use information as a way to build the capacity of people to problem-solve together.

Is there a group that springs to mind for you? Jot down its name on our nomination form. Help us catalog the people stepping up to make sure good information is flowing in their communities. Let's get a sense of our foundation and then start shoring it up. Nominate early and often until Nov. 30!

Until next week, take care, travel safe, and try to get some rest. If you are interested in joining us for empathy book club this Sunday, we'd love to have you. Catch up on what you missed if you'd like. We'll be moving on to Chapter 3.

Oh! And I promised Simon Galperin I would make sure to remind any of you near Newark, N.J., that The Jersey Bee is hosting a comedy showcase at the Newark Museum of Art on Dec. 11. We all could use a laugh.